Going to Court? Book Your Free First Appointment

Making a False Statement about the Contamination of Goods With Intent (Constitutional Offence)

Making a false statement about the contamination of goods with intent (constitutional offence) is a crime under section 380.4(2) of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), which carries a maximum penalty of 15 years in prison.

To establish the offence, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that:

  1. You made a statement
  2. You knew your statement was false
  3. You did so intending to induce the person to whom the statement was made or others to believe goods had been contaminated.
  1. You did so intending to cause:
  1. Public alarm or anxiety, or
  2. Economic loss through public awareness of the actual or possible contamination of goods, and
  1. Any of the following apply:
  1. the loss is to a constitutional corporation other than a foreign corporation
  2. the loss is to a constitutional corporation that is a foreign corporation, and the goods have been produced, manufactured, assembled or otherwise processed in Australia
  3. the goods belong to a constitutional corporation other than a foreign corporation
  4. the goods belong to a constitutional corporation that is a foreign corporation, and the goods have been produced, manufactured, assembled or otherwise processed in Australia
  5. you are a constitutional corporation other than a foreign corporation
  6. you are a constitutional corporation that is a foreign corporation, and the goods have been produced, manufactured, assembled or otherwise processed in Australia
  7. the loss takes the form of detriment to constitutional trade and commerce
  8. the goods are in the course of, or intended for, constitutional trade and commerce
  9. you make the subject statement in Australia using a postal or other like service, or by electronic communication
  10. you make the subject statement outside Australia, and the goods have been produced, manufactured, assembled or otherwise processed in Australia
  11. the incurred loss is to the Commonwealth or a Commonwealth authority, or
  12. your statement is made to the Commonwealth or a Commonwealth authority.

‘Goods’ include any substance:

  1. Whether or not for human consumption
  2. Whether natural or manufactured, and
  3. Whether or not incorporated or mixed with other goods.

To ‘contaminate’ goods includes:

  1. To interfere with goods, and
  2. To make it appear that goods have been contaminated or interfered with.

‘Economic loss’ includes monetary loss caused through:

  1. Members of the public not purchasing or using those goods or similar things, and
  2. Steps taken to avoid public alarm or anxiety or to avoid harm to members of the public.

Duress and necessity are defences to the charge.

What Our Clients Say SEE ALL

  • ★★★★★

    Went above and beyond to secure a favourable outcome

    Rasheen Mahmodian provided great legal advice and went above and beyond to secure a favourable…

  • ★★★★★

    The outcome was even better than expected

    Karina Diec was absolutely amazing, could not fault her efforts, dedication, advice and just making…

  • ★★★★★

    Professional work ethic, and lovely to work with such nice and understanding lawyers

    If you ever need a lawyer this is the best firm to go to, such…

  • ★★★★★

    Great outcome, no conviction

    Great outcome, no conviction which has helped keep my job! Thanks to Mehnet Yilmaz.

Going to Court? Call For Your Free First Appointment