Australia Needs a Human Rights Act, Not Antisemitism Envoy’s Pro Israel Wrecking Ball

The next plank of Australia’s Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism (ASECA) Jillian Segal’s Plan to Combat Antisemitism has been announced. It involves new school curriculum aimed at expanding awareness of Jewish culture and prejudice against Jews. And this is despite the Albanese government having laid the path to deliver laws to protect the rights of all groups prior to Segal’s appointment.
Segal was appointed to ASECA in July 2024, due to local fallout caused by 7 October 2023 Hamas attacks on Israel and the ongoing Gaza genocide. The antisemitism envoy framework was established in the United States in 2004, and pressure from the US state department is likely to have led to the appointment. The goal of the envoy’s is to overhaul local institutions to guard against antisemitism.
The ASECA’s plan aims to protect against antisemitism, considered to be rising post the outbreak of the Israeli perpetrated Gaza genocide, despite this nation’s existing antidiscrimination framework. And this raises questions as to why an unelected official has been empowered to overhaul all institutions in this manner, when frameworks to protect all constituents were already in the works.
Indeed, the month prior to Segal’s appointment, the stage had been set by the Albanese government, to enact a Human Rights Act, which would uphold the rights of all, no matter what their creed. Whilst the National Anti-Racism Framework, released in the months after the envoy took office, guards against targeted prejudice toward all groups in the community and not just one.
So, rather than the nation progressing a HRA and an all-encompassing antiracism scheme for all, the ASECA is progressing her plan, which at its heart seeks to deflect criticism of Israel, via the guise of preventing antisemitism. So, in this manner Labor isn’t delivering protections for any constituents and instead, has handed Segal the keys to the polity, so she can construct a shield to protect Israel.
Israelising Australian institutions
The ASECA position was foisted onto the Australian public by the prime minister in July 2024. And while the PM did flag that she was then on her way to Argentina to join other global envoys on antisemitism from other western nations, the focus of the announcement more so involved the slated additional appointment of an Islamophobia envoy, which happened three months later.
Segal’s Plan to Combat Antisemitism was released in July 2025. At its heart, it seeks the adoption of the IHRA (International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance) working definition on antisemitism “across all levels of government, public institutions and regulatory bodies”. The IHRA includes eleven examples of antisemitism, seven of which involve Israel, and this serves to suppress critics of Israel.
On release of Segal’s whole-of-society overhaul, the Albanese government left the plan unactioned. But after the 14 December 2025 Bondi Beach massacre saw 15 Jewish people murdered in a targeted ISIS attack, the then beleaguered PM, who was copping criticism from the local Israel lobby as if the shooting was his fault, announced the rollout of the plan three days after the mass casualty event.
The IHRA serves to conflate antisemitism with criticism of Israel. The mechanism blocks this because it’s deemed prejudicial towards Jews and Judaism. Since the 2016 IHRA Plenary adopted the definition, it’s been wielded to counter anti-Israel critics in this manner. But prior to the IHRA, Zionists, or advocates of Israel, had been making a similar conflation to block criticism for decades.
So far, the Australian envoy’s plan has seen AHPRA, the national health regulator, adopt the IHRA definition, which now means medics face backlash if openly critical of Israeli human rights abuses, whilst Palestinians may face discrimination in the health system. And local universities have adopted a variation of the IHRA definition, although Segal now wants these institutions to adopt the original.
The combat antisemitism changes set to be rolled out to secondary schools next year will see Jewish components taught within several different subject areas. This has been sold as Holocaust education, however that is already part of school curriculum. And year 10 students will in the future be required to identify antisemitism and push back on it, prior to graduating.
Detering discrimination against all groups
The peculiar aspect to the rising antisemitism claims leading to the roll out of the plan is that these were accompanied by reports of rising Islamophobia. However, there has been no rush to institute whole-of-society reform to combat Islamophobia. And further, the most detrimental prejudice in this country is against First Nations people, so any overhaul framework ought to combat that prejudice.
The brainchild of the 2021 Race Discrimination commissioner, the National Anti-Racism Framework was released by the Australian Human Rights Commission in November 2024. Yet, after investing $7.5 million into developing the framework in October 2022, the Albanese government went on to ignore its release, and 12 months later, federal Labor rather adopted Segal’s plan.
Close to completion when Segal was appointed, the National Anti-Racism Framework provides a “whole-of-society approach to eliminating racism”. And similar to Segal’s plan, the framework serves to reform government systems, as well as nongovernment organisations, businesses and civil society organisations to undertake antiracist action to end such prejudice within all these institutions.
The AHRC further released a comprehensive March 2023 report recommending the establishment of a federal Human Rights Act. Unlike the anti-Racism framework, in response to the HRA report, the Albanese government announced a parliamentary inquiry into the nation’s human rights framework, which on reporting back in May 2024, recommended that the nation enact a federal HRA.
Australian continues to be the only western democracy on the planet without a HRA or a bill of rights. A HRA serves to enshrine rights in law. It requires lawmakers to consider human rights when drafting laws, government authorities cannot breach these rights, and individuals would have legal recourse when their rights are being infringed upon.
So, in 2024, two lawmaking initiatives the Albanese government had long set in motion to produce laws to uphold the rights of all constituents and provide antiracism protection to all were shelved, because the priority suddenly became the establishment of two envoys to protect against particular prejudices and then, ultimately, to provide a framework to protect solely against antisemitism.
A tale of one prejudice
Aftab Malik was announced as Australia’s Special Envoy to Combat Islamophobia on 30 September 2024, three months after Segal’s appointment. Malik’s National Response to Islamophobia was released a year later, and it provides a framework for government departments to proactively combat Islamophobia, without any addition of a strict definition to guide it like Segal’s plan.
The Albanese government responded to the Islamophobia report in July 2026, more than half a year after it adopted Segal’s plan in full. And unlike the antisemitism report, federal Labor has only committed to two-thirds of Malik’s recommendations, which are nowhere near as disruptive as Segal’s reforms, as his plan aims at combatting Islamophobia via education and awareness.
Much of the community is unaware that the Islamophobia envoy has created a plan similar to the antisemitism envoy. Not only has Malik’s work been ignored in the public sphere, whilst Segal’s input has been prioritised, but the Islamophobia envoy’s plan to stamp out prejudice against Muslims is not backed by an international network seeking to provide cover to a foreign settler colonial project.
And the most heinous aspect to the wrecking ball Segal has taken to this country’s institutions, whilst Albanese stands idly by watching on, is that rather than engage in the truth-telling process to unpack and grapple with the disinformation disseminated about the founding of this nation, the lies propagated to provide cover for the genociding of Palestinians are being institutionalised in Australia.
Image: Official photo of Jillian Segal from the Antisemitism Envoy website. Israeli wrecking ball from Shutterstock. The official portrait of Anthony Albanese is licensed under CC BY 4.0.





