A Photo Tells a Thousand Lies: Uncovering Untruths About Photographic Evidence

Digital evidence such as computer-generated images, videos, emails, text messages and social media messages and posts can be incredibly persuasive when it comes to decisions as to whether criminal charges are brought and continued, as well as in establishing allegations inside the courtroom.
But it is important to bear in mind that material which ostensibly appears to be suggestive of guilt is not always as it appears – a problem compounded by the advent of artificial intelligence, and accelerated by the proliferation of misinformation, disinformation and other nefarious material, including deepfakes.
In such an environment, it is crucial for criminal defence lawyers to be sceptical and vigilant when it comes to determining the veracity of digital evidence – a process which requires knowledge of, or at least access to, skills in examining and determining whether the presented material is accurate and reliable.
Digital files
Digital files such as photographs, and video or audio recordings, are frequently used to corroborate other evidence, and may even be relied upon to independently establish facts in a case – including what occurred, the person/s involved and the location of an alleged incident.
But a digital file (or material allegedly generated from one) is not always what it appears to be – and should not prima facie be relied upon to establish such matters.
Digital evidence can easily be created, edited or otherwise altered to fit a desired narrative, and it is crucial to insist on receiving – whether by request, subpoena or notice to produce – the original digital files and associated metadata.
This is particularly important when such material is produced by those with a personal interest in a case, such as complainants or those who are close to them.
Indeed, our firm has over the years been able to have many dozen criminal prosecutions discontinued, or dismissed in court, by undermining the veracity of digital evidence – enabling our clients to move forward with their lives.
All specialist criminal defence lawyer will, or at least should, be able to undertake cursory examinations of digital files as well as its associated metadata with a view to detecting tell-tale signs of inauthenticity and/or editing. Our firm has an in-house forensic field manual as well as forensic investigation flow charts to assist with this process.
A digital forensic expert may then be briefed for a report confirming and often expanding upon our findings.
Some of the questions that may be consider upon receiving a digital file (or material allegedly generated from one) include:
Is it the original digital file?
Police will often supply the defence with printed pages, images embedded in software such as PDF or selected parts of videos or audio recordings.
These are rarely acceptable, as they are unlikely to contain the original digital footprints such as recorded capture time, GPS coordinates or other associated metadata, and may also fail to put the alleged incident in context, especially if only parts of video or audio recordings are served, or if photos expected to have been served are not served.
Once again, original files must always be obtained – whether by request or, if refused, by way of subpoena or notice to produce.
This is, of course, especially important when the material is inconsistent with the defence position.
Once the alleged original digital files are obtained, an initial examination should be undertaken with a view to identifying any tell-tale signs of inauthenticity.
Does an initial examination stack up?
A cursory examination of a digital file may include answering questions such as:
Photographs
What is the date of the photograph taken? The creation and encoded timestamps are relevant in that regard.
Do the timestamps correspond with the allegations and other evidence in the case?
Could the date on the file have been changed?
Is there GPS coordinates? If so, have they been checked?
Does a reverse image search need to be undertaken?
What device captured the image?
Is it an original, a screenshot or an export?
Does the file contain EXIF or Embedded Metadata?
Could the capture date and time have been modified?
Does the time zone explain any discrepancies, was there day light savings?
Was the image ever published and shared online on social media and when?
Does the file show evidence of cropping, resizing or editing?
Who possessed or controlled the original image?
Is there a documented chain of custody?
What conclusions can reliably be drawn from the image, and what remains unverified or open to alternative interpretation?
Videos
What is the date and time the video was recorded? The creation and encoded timestamps are relevant in that regard.
Do the timestamps correspond with the allegations and other evidence in the case?
Could the recording date or time have been manually changed?
Does the recording contain metadata identifying the device, software or application used?
What device or program originally captured the video recording?
Is the video an original recording, an exported file, a screen recording or a copy?
Is the recording complete, or does it only show a selected portion of the incident?
Could there be footage before or after the recording that may provide additional context?
Are there unexplained gaps, missing frames or interruptions in the recording?
Does the frame rate, resolution or compression affect the ability to identify people, objects or movements?
Does a close visual examination suggest evidence of editing, trimming, cropping or splicing?
Could the camera angle, lighting, distance or obstructions create a misleading impression?
Is the footage sufficiently clear to reliably identify the individuals involved?
Does the video contain GPS coordinates or other location information, and has that information been verified?
Is there a clear chain of custody?
Has the original recording been obtained and properly preserved?
Does the video contain audio, and if so, is it synchronised with the footage?
Could the audio have been replaced, altered, or added after the recording?
Does the recording accurately reflect the sequence and timing of events?
What conclusions can reliably be drawn from the recording, and what remains unverified or open to alternative interpretation?
Audio
What is the date and time the audio recording was created? The creation and encoded timestamps are relevant in that regard.
Do the timestamps correspond with the allegations and other evidence in the case?
Could the recording date or time have been changed?
What device, application or recording system captured the audio?
Is the file an original recording, an export, a copy or a recording of another recording?
Does the audio contain embedded metadata identifying the recording device, software or creation date?
Has the original audio file been obtained and preserved?
Is the recording complete, or has only a selected portion been provided?
Are there unexplained gaps, abrupt transitions, silences or interruptions?
Does a close examination suggest evidence of editing, trimming, cropping or splicing?
Could background noise, interference, compression or poor recording quality affect what can be heard?
Has the audio been enhanced, filtered or processed, and could that processing affect its interpretation?
Can the people speaking in the audio be reliably identified, and what evidence supports their identification?
Could the recording contain multiple people speaking, whose voices have been incorrectly attributed?
Has any voice identification been independently verified where necessary?
Is the conversation presented in its proper context? For example, are there preceding or subsequent conversations that could change the meaning of the recorded statements?
Could words or phrases have been misheard or incorrectly transcribed?
Has any transcript if available, been checked against the original recording?
Are there disputed or unclear words that require independent examination or needing interpretation?
Could the audio have been generated or manipulated using artificial intelligence, including voice cloning or deepfake technology?
Does the recording contain background sounds that could assist in verifying the location, circumstances or timing?
Have the recording time, time zone and any device clock discrepancies been considered?
Was the audio originally recorded during a telephone call, through a messaging application or using a separate recording device?
Could the recording or export process have altered the audio quality or removed relevant metadata?
Who originally made the recording, and who possessed or controlled the original file?
Is there a documented chain of custody?
What conclusions can reliably be drawn from the recording, and what remains unverified or open to alternative interpretation?
Helpful hints and other matters to consider
The created and enclosed timestamps within a video, audio or photo of an original digital file will normally match, or be very similar.
That said, matching timestamps do not necessarily establish authenticity – a number of the other listed matters must be considered when determining this.
Timestamps that do not match are a strong indication of inauthenticity.
Another matter to consider is the time zone where the file was made and whether an incorrect time clock has been used. The metadata will provide evidence of the time zone and cross referencing the file with other material may suggest the clock attached to the recording device is inaccurate.
Social media can be a surprisingly useful way to determine authenticity in the event the user has uploaded, published or shared on social media. Metadata can be extracted from social media material.
A basic example – the article image
The image at the top of this article depicts a group of people walking along a mountain range.
It was in fact taken during a Sydney Criminal Lawyers team trip to Queenstown, New Zealand.
Now, suppose the image represented alibi evidence that one of the depicted persons was overseas when an alleged offence occurred within Australia
The information below can be immediately extracted from the Apple phone using Apple Photo Information Panel is as follows:
| Date: 4 June 2022 |
| Time: 3:36 pm |
| Location: Queenstown, New Zealand |
| Device: Apple iPhone 13 Pro Max |
| File format: HEIF |
| Resolution: 3024 × 4032 pixels |
| File size: 3.3 MB |
The image was later sent by email and the information extracted from the emailed image using Windows File Manager is as follows:
| The emailed photograph examined through Windows File Properties displayed: |
| Date created: 15 October 2026 |
| Time created: 12:07:22 am |
And the information extracted from the emailed JPEG is as follows:
| Date modified: 15 October 2026 |
| File format: JPG |
| File size: Approximately 1.01 MB |
| Camera information: Not displayed in the General Properties tab |
| GPS information: Not displayed in the General Properties tab |
Most notable, of course, is the difference in dates between the information extracted from the original device using Apple software and emailed image. There is also a significant difference in the file size.
It is important to note that the Apple information is not conclusive of date, time and location as Apple Photos allows users to adjust the displayed date, time and location, and to add or edit a caption.
That being the case, it is necessary to obtain the original .HEIC file from the device on which the photo was captured. The standard tool used to extract original data is ExifTool. However, the timestamp extracted using that tool is not necessarily proof of a particular time.
The next step is therefore it to compare the created date and the encoded or modified date. As previously outlined, a difference in those times is evidence that the original information has not been provided, and that the file is therefore inauthentic. Other data to check includes the extracted time zone, GPS Stamp, make and model of the phone and any software used.
There are, of course, many other checks that can be undertaken; which can culminate in a mountain of evidence that an image is unreliable.
Information such as this can often be used to exclude evidence in court or, even better, to have charges withdrawn or downgraded at an early time in the proceedings – especially where there is insufficient information to establish that an image, or audio or video file, that is central to the case is authentic, and in fact appears to be inauthentic through extracted data.
A case study
A recent case handled by our firm demonstrates how early forensic examination of digital evidence can significantly influence the outcome of criminal proceedings.
The matter involved a client who was charged with intimidation and using a carriage service to menace, harass or cause offence following a disputed telephone conversation. An application for an apprehended violence order was also made.
The allegations relied, in part, upon an audio recording supplied to police by a complainant.
Our client disputed the allegations and maintained that the recording did not accurately represent the conversation in its entirety.
Our office commenced an examination of the available digital evidence to assess the reliability and completeness of the recording.
One of the first steps was to compare the duration of the audio file supplied to police with the telephone call information recorded on the receiving device.
The audio file supplied was approximately was just under a minute, police alleged that was the entire call duration without any investigative work such as obtaining the telephone records from the subscriber. Our team obtained those details and cross checked the metadata source and proved the call was more than double that duration.
This raised important questions about whether the complete conversation had been provided and whether additional material was available.
Further examination of the file’s metadata identified discrepancies between the recorded timestamps and the time of the telephone conversation. These findings required consideration of whether the file was an original recording, an exported version or a subsequently processed copy.
Our office sought access to the original recording which could not be produced by the complainant who advised police they lost their phone after we pressed the police to investigate properly to enable a more comprehensive assessment. However, the original source material was not made available for independent examination.
The findings of our preliminary investigation were subsequently referred to an independent digital forensic specialist, who prepared an expert report addressing the technical issues identified.
The report was provided to police, and the criminal charges and apprehended violence order proceedings were subsequently withdrawn.
It also illustrates the value of undertaking preliminary forensic investigations within a criminal defence practice before engaging an independent expert.
By identifying potential evidentiary issues early, lawyers can ensure that expert examinations are appropriately focused, relevant material is requested and unnecessary costs are minimised.
Ultimately, digital evidence should be assessed not merely by what it appears to depict or record, but by what can reliably be established about its origin, completeness, integrity and context.
A careful and methodical approach can reveal weaknesses in evidence that may otherwise go unnoticed and, in appropriate cases, contribute to criminal charges being withdrawn or successfully defended.





