Removing Social Licence to Sue People into Silence: Interview with Stop the SLAPP Alliance’s Aish Cowgill

Recent years have seen an increasing number of cases raised against critics of Israel by powerful lobby groups in Australia. These cases don’t appear to have the legs to get across the line, but nonetheless, they run them to penalise those targeted with the inconvenience and expense of defending themselves. And the Australian Democracy Network is now seeking to rein in this practice.
Such suits are known as SLAPP (strategic litigation against public participation) suits, and they involve a more powerful entity bringing a case against less powerful individuals, whom the plaintiff is seeking to silence.
The Australian Democracy Network launched its Stop the SLAPP campaign on Gadigal land at the Sydney Masonic Centre on 10 November 2026.
This campaign involves the Stop the SLAPP Alliance, which is a coalition of over 35 legal and civil society organisations progressing the campaign. These include the Human Rights Legal Centre (HRLC), the Working Women’s Centre Australia, New South Wales Council for Civil Liberties, Gender Justice Australia, the Bob Brown Foundation and Amnesty International.
In the forward to the HRLC’s Stop the SLAPP report, former Australian Greens leader Bob Brown recalls that in December 2004, Australian logging company Gunns “slapped 20 Tasmanian people and groups with a $6.3 million writ two days before it announced plans for one of the world’s biggest pulp mills, its aim was to stymie environmental opposition”.
Brown was one of the people Gunns targeted. The Gunns case dragged on for five years, over which time those targeted had this unresolved issue hanging over their heads, as well as the expense of running their defence. Gunns went on to gradually drop the case against some defendants over time, and it then settled with the final four applicants in 2010, just days before the case was to go to court.
Australian Democracy Network democracy campaigner Aish Cowgill explains that since the launch of the campaign last week, there has been something of a collective sigh of relief as many who’d considered that SLAPP suits are simply a nasty aspect of the legal system were made aware that the campaign aims to see federal laws enacted that can serve to end SLAPP suits after they’re raised.
Sydney Criminal Lawyers spoke to the Australian Democracy Network’s Aish Cowgill about how one can identify that a legal challenge is a SLAPP suit, the legal mechanisms that can be set in place that would allow those targeted to challenge such a case from going ahead, and the fact that she and other ADN members will be down in Canberra lobbying for these changes next week.

Over recent years, there have been a number of high-profile legal suits launched by powerful entities in Australia that are designed to silence critics speaking uncomfortable truths in the public arena.
SLAPP suits are types of legal challenges raised against individuals, which don’t necessarily attempt to succeed, but rather, it’s the public shaming of the individual the suit targets, the expense of fighting it for them and the time-consuming nature of such proceedings, that are the purpose of such litigation. These negative effects are designed to intimidate these people into silence.
SLAPP suits haven’t always been progressed in the Australian legal system. Many critics consider that they are at odds with the rule of law.
So, Aish, how does it come to be that these types of cases that do appear to take advantage of the way in which the legal system operates have become so prevalent over recent decades to the point that at present they appear all the rage?
As you said, with SLAPP suits the process becomes the punishment. In the current state of our legal system, the wealthy and powerful can simply outspend anyone into silence.
We have extremely powerful and well-resourced corporations in this country who can essentially outspend anyone that criticises them or brings criticism against them.
And by targeting victim-survivors, whistleblowers and activists, more people lose their ability to speak out, and then as the public, we lose our ability to find out and then push back.
That’s why, like forty other jurisdictions across the world, we do need anti-SLAPP laws to stop this problem from getting worse.
For decades, we have seen these suits, like the Gunns litigation against environmental campaigners. But today, these suits effect a diverse cohort, including journalists, whisteblowers and also women speaking out about sexual violence.
Right now, it appears that people are being hit with SLAPP suits, and whilst the target of such litigation can suggest that the purpose of a suit is to intimidate them, that’s about all they can do, besides lawyering up and fighting the claim made against them.
So, how can one identify that a legal filing is a SLAPP suit? And what are some of the most prominent impacts and outcomes that these cases do have upon those targeted?
The clues to identifying a SLAPP are often a powerful individual or corporation using extremely aggressive, disproportionate or very costly legal tactics, against a person or organisation that are engaging in activities of public interest, and this also includes reporting on or speaking out against sexual violence.
We have seen a number of cases where the environmental movement, victim-survivors or journalists are pursued by incredibly powerful people and organisations.
So, for example, the recent Woodside case against protesters in Western Australia, which had its decision handed down in July. In that case, it would have cost more to take their lawyers to court than the actual damages they were seeking.
The impact with that case didn’t just stop with the defendant. Our communities and other people watched that legal bloodbath that a person or organisation is going through and then decide it is safer to remain silent, which is a chilling effect.
So, litigation against one can silence an entire movement.
The Australian Democracy Network has just launched the Stop the SLAPP Alliance, which is a coalition of more than 35 legal and civil society organisations campaigning to bring about an end to these types of legal cases. The Alliance wants to establish anti-SLAPP protections, as other nations have established.
So, can you talk about the type of mechanisms the Alliance hopes to establish, so that people who have been targeted by a SLAPP suit are able to avoid having their lives destroyed?
We are very fortunate, as we have 40-plus other jurisdictions who already have these kinds of laws. So, we know the ones that work and the ones that don’t.
This sets us up in a good position to implement a best practice model.
We know these cases ruin people’s lives, and they get in the way of change to make a better society. They almost always involve stopping people from speaking the truth.
The legislation that we are proposing would allow a SLAPP target to bring a motion to stay proceedings, and then dismiss the proceedings, unless the powerful party can prove that the case is not a SLAPP.
So, if they can’t, then the case is dismissed, and the powerful party may have to pay indemnity costs for bringing the SLAPP action in the first place.
We have seen these laws work overseas, including in very high-profile cases, in which these laws have been used by celebrities against perpetrators of sexual violence, including Phoebe Bridgers and Evan Rachel Wood in defamation cases that were brought against them in the US.
So, you’re talking about laws that will not only prevent a SLAPP suit from proceeding, but those who might also be considering launching such a suit may think twice as it could result in punishment?
Yes. So, at the moment, there is no disincentive from bringing these types of cases or for making these threats against people.
But with legislation like this that actually involves a punishment, we would be removing the social license for these tactics to be used by making a statement that it is unacceptable.
Also, this law would act as a deterrent to those organisations from bringing these types of cases.
The Australian Democracy Network seeks to promote a healthy democracy in this country. However, the ADN notes that SLAPP suits actually undermine basic democratic principles.
Can you talk about why that is the case?
SLAPPs add a massive price to speaking out. This is a price so high that to speak out risks gambling with your own or your organisation’s future.
We know that the biggest victories for change over the last decade have been brought about by incredibly brave people speaking out.
This includes Brittany Higgins, who created a national conversation about sexual violence, as well as Ben Pennings, who took on a multimillion-dollar mining corporation to protect our climate.
We know a democracy can’t work when money determines who gets heard and who gets silenced.
And, lastly, Aish, the Stop the SLAPP Alliance is calling on the federal government to introduce standalone laws to prevent rising legal manoeuvrers designed to silence often grassroots critics.
But federal politicians are some of the types of powerful entities that are known to readily consider this sort of option when someone is being vocally critical against them.
So, how does the Stop the SLAPP Alliance plan to move its campaign forward? What sort of support is out there more generally? And how can people get involved?
The Alliance is made up of 38 diverse organisations. These include media organisations to gender justice to community legal centres. And we’ve been finding out that there is actually broad support across the political spectrum.
Very few believe the law should be used as a weapon in this way. In fact, from the data that we have obtained, most people are surprised that the law can be used in this way.
In the last week, we have had even more interest since our public launch, and if organisations are interested in joining the alliance they can reach out and complete the expression of interest on StoptheSLAPP.com.au.
And any other individuals who want to join the campaign can also do so by signing our petition calling for federal protections.
We will be in Canberra next week, alongside Jennifer Robinson, speaking to politicians across parliament about these critical reforms.
Alliances like ours have won reforms in Europe, Ireland and the US. And we believe that working in solidarity also makes it possible here.
Main image of silenced woman from Shutterstock





